The Uterine Exile.

Written in April 2019 for COMS 591: Senior Seminar in Communication and Media, University of Calgary.

The contributions of women to gene editing have largely been shrouded in the socio-cultural constructions of motherhood. The medical community discourse entraps the woman with her womb using the cultural relations of power. How does a woman reconcile the public iterations of her motherhood with the denial of her own body autonomy? She is silenced by ascribing the potency of her agency to her uterus. She functions as an extension of the womb. Presuppositions of gene editing have often been the focus of general criticism, with particular fixations on its benefits or detriments. Gene editing involves making a change in the genetic material of an organism by inserting new genetic material through “knocking down, activating or inactivating a gene” (Simonstein 2017). The two types of gene editing- somatic and germ-line, are not without consequences. While the somatic gene editing targets all other cells excluding the reproductive cells in an organism, germline editing focuses squarely on reproductive cells capable of developing into a new organism. In humans, this procedure is particularly complex, due to the possibility of the gene modifications becoming hereditary. The success of germ-line gene editing depends on In Vitro Fertilisation (IVF) and Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD). Therefore, the female participation is invaluable and a determinant of its future. However, this critical factor is mostly addressed only in minor details. CRISPR, frequently touted as the ultimate form of precision medicine, is capable of curing complex illnesses like HIV, Cancer, Diabetes and more. It stands for “Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats” and when used for germ-line editing, functions as a tool to rewrite DNA and is capable of altering the genome before diseases materialize. However, the access of germ-line cells functions differently for men and women. The approach is quick and non-invasive for men but time-consuming and invasive for women (Stevenson, 2016). The introduction of CRISPR and its perceived ability to alter heritable diseases, places women at the forefront of bio-ethical and moral concerns in relation to their reproductive systems. This introduction creates possible circumstances in which women could be obligated to adopt IVF for reproduction. Therefore, in order to “save” the future generation, gene editing will become gendered (Simonstein, 2017). In an article detailing the effect of gene editing on women’s reproductive health, Stevenson relays the difficulty of IVF on the body of women and its further financial limitations. She explains the complexities that are prone to arise with the introduction of CRISPR and argues that it will expand the scope of women who use IVF from those with fertility problems to those who want “an additional genetic level of control over the health and well being of her child” (Stevenson, 2016). Doudna further declares that, “research aimed at circumventing infertility had inadvertently refined a procedure that would become integral to future discussions of germline modification” (Doudna, 2017). The effects of the burden are far reaching. The woman and her womb simultaneously become responsible for the wellbeing of the future. Hence, it becomes a moral responsibility and a potentially legal one. Most important is the socio-cultural expectation of the motherhood. Many proponents of gene editing posit that it is a responsibility and moral duty of the society to protect the future generations from preventable genetic diseases. While this lofty declaration is not without great benefits, the burden placed on the woman to fulfil these obligations is often ignored. If it is a moral duty to prevent these genetic diseases, is it then immoral for the woman to choose to procreate without IVF? The goal of this paper is to explicate the socio-cultural hold the society places on the woman and her womb. Using a feminist approach, this paper will deconstruct the inequalities inherent in reproductive rights of the woman by focusing on the patriarchal approach to research on germ-line gene editing and the possible moralistic, legalistic and futuristic implications on the woman. This will be accomplished by illustrating the woman as an extension of her womb; an entity she is subject to rather than in control of. Starting with the exploration of Simone de Beauvoir’s declaration of the public imposition of the woman as a “womb-man”, this paper will delve into the possible obligations of the woman's womb to society. Then it will explore the possibilities of ectogenesis and feminist approaches to it, and finally the fractured relationship between the woman and the societal definitions of womanhood.

When Simone de Beauvoir first asked in her feminist epoch, “What is a woman?” and recorded the old answer, “woman is a womb”, germ-line editing did not exist. With its introduction, a myriad of responsibilities and burdens espoused by the society as beneficial scientific progression has positioned women at uncomfortable crossroads that alienates their ability to channel their agencies beyond the capabilities of their uterus. This consistent handicap is obscured by the medical community, mostly males, who deem germ-line editing a moral responsibility with immense capabilities at saving the world, while simultaneously ignoring the vehicle being employed for the “noble mission.” In their persistent proclamations of germ-line gene editing as the saving grace of the future generation, few admissions have been made concerning the ease of extracting the germ-line cells of the man or the exclusion from the emotional and physiological responsibilities the woman has to assume to succumb to the vagaries of IVF required for its success. Like Beauvoir declares, a man would not be tasked with writing this sort of paper, he has no need to assert his masculinity when the society has decided that it is the bedrock of reproductive ideology. Beauvoir declares, “the man represents both the positive and the neutral, as is indicated by the common use of man to designate human beings in general; whereas woman represents only the negative, defined by limiting criteria, without reciprocity” (Beauvoir, 1952). How does the woman fare with choosing between the health of the future generation and the physiological powerlessness she faces over her body? Feminists have differing views on the politics of gene editing and the role of the woman in its propagation. They do, however, agree about the inequality in reproductive autonomy. What then is a woman's role in germ-line editing? Is her presence required or solely the interactions with her womb? A common argument for germ-line editing focuses specifically on the rights of the embryo while negating the rights of its carrier. This renders the woman, an other and her womb- the absolute. The womb is the covert progenitor and the woman herself, defined by its whims. This duality is what will influence the rest of this paper. When Beauvoir declares that the woman is viewed as “thinking with her glands” and is weighed down by her ovaries and all the organs presumed to make her whole, she captures the hackneyed tale that the woman is the sum of her parts; parts that are deemed weaker than a man's. The wellbeing of the woman is of no concern, she is only considered necessary for her womb. Even then, her necessity is not proclaimed. Doudna details her skepticism of gene editing in the hand of fertility doctors asking, “…will they really pause to reflect on the possible consequences? Or will they rush to make use of this newfound power…”; this concern directly correlates with the fear of the monstrous burden a woman’s body will be put through to fulfil gene editing procedures (Doudna, 2017). Doudna’s fears are not unfounded due to the “utopian perfectionism” imposed by the medical community in service to biocapitalism (Peters, 2010). The reality of the minority woman is far worse. The minority woman has always been on the disenfranchised side of hegemonic dictations. The story of the use of Henrietta Lacks’ cells are infamous for such exclusions. The state places the power of discourse in the hands of the man and the “governmental technologies play a central role in power relations” (Peters, 2010).

The relegation of the agency of the woman to the functions of her uterus is a retelling of the subordination myth. It is a repackaged form of domestication. Ribbens argues that “domestication is used to enslave women through the womb and has been turned into powerlessness” (Ribbens, 1994). Beauvoir’s explication of the idea that one “thinks thus because one is a woman” is a by product of this domestication. The man that speaks of the morality of gene editing and the burden the society must carry is not tasked with the physical responsibility of submitting his body to the desires of the state. His body is not prodded, neither does the world juxtapose his parenthood with the functions of his reproductive glands, he instead sits still in the shadow compelling her to render her womb, her idol. Her worth is tied to her uterine fecundity, which she is soon exiled from. Using a comparative discourse analysis to sift the framing of the socio-cultural consciousness of gene editing, unearths the underlying issues. The concept of morality is woven into it intricately. It can be argued that it is morally reprehensible to abstain from gene editing due to its potential benefits. To look at the scope of possibilities it presents and to disavow its merit due to its perceived disadvantages, can be categorized as a fatal mistake. However, this does not equate to the lack of consent from the woman. Morality is often intertwined with the law, which in turn governs bodies. If gene editing is accepted and becomes a gendered project, women might become required to reproduce with IVF. This succumbs a woman’s body to severe emotional burdens. Simonstein argues that this reproductive inequality is because “women and only women are expected to bear children” (Simonstein, 2017). Simonstein’s suggestion of ectogenesis- nurturing the embryo outside the womb, has differing feminist views (Simonstein, 2017). The approach to exploring the complexities of germ-line gene editing while ignoring its effects on the woman's body is patriarchal. Happe states, “The history of women’s struggle to secure reproductive and bodily autonomy defies any easy narrative. The struggle between women, the state, and the medical community has resulted in disturbing paradoxes” (Happe, 1998). The medical community has continuously focused on the idea that genetic modification is a choice. The idea of even a sliver of an autonomous alternative for women is laughable. One might argue that there is no coercion, but there is judgment. In Levine’s article about genetic cloning, specifically prenatal baby design, she addresses the issue of the financial divide any form of genetic modification causes. This will particularly affect minority women. This financial incapability can complicate possible feelings of inadequacies and moral guilt. Proponents of gene editing insist on the rights of the embryo above the wellbeing of the woman which renders the woman’s body a vehicle to fulfill the socio-cultural wishes of the society. Happe declares her body “an incubator for the state.” The danger behind these socio-cultural pressures are threefold. Their moralistic inception into the public consciousness is being discussed but the potential legalistic and futuristic implications cannot be underestimated. Happe declares, “Women’s bodies and behaviors are at times pathologized to secure vaguely construed state or fetal interests” (Happe, 1998). While the futuristic implications are tied to moralism, the legalistic effects could be attached to the definitions of motherhood. Could the law deem it feasible to determine the actions and boundaries required of a woman’s womb to consider her a mother? Happe succinctly explains the intricacies of the societal dictatorship, stating, “The factors by which a woman is deemed fit to mother are socially and culturally determined, despite the history of confusing natural and social categories in genetic discourse” (Happe, 1998). Happe further describes in detail the policing of women’s bodies by the state. On the issue of arguing about the right of a fetus unborn, she says, that it has been argued that women should be held liable for “carrying a genetically defective fetus to term” (Happe, 1998). It is not farfetched to imagine the legalization of policing a woman’s reproductive rights. Furthermore, proponents argue that nearly all new technological developments have primarily been deemed to have unpredictable effects on future generations and every predetermination of gene editing is a slippery-slope of unproven assumptions. Tracing the patriarchal proclivity for subjugating female reproductive autonomy is not a misandrous machination, it is a summoning for conscious inspection of the hegemonic female reproductive entrapment.

The financial divide is an important phenomenon in the consideration of the access to germ-line gene editing. In addition to the physical difficulty, IVF is responsible for in a woman’s body, its financial burden is crucial. Gene editing technologies have the potential of amplifying these financial implications. If germ-line gene editing is accepted as the feasible and safest method of preventing genetic diseases, IVF will become a colossal requirement for attempting such reversals. With a success rate between 13-43% and cycles of quantifiable health risks, the woman’s body is subject to more emotional burden and introspection in determining the right decision for her reproductive future (Stevenson, 2016). Savulescu’s proclamation of gene editing as a social responsibility and sacrifice negates the burden of such emotional decisions (Savulescu, 2015). Is a mother then socially irresponsible for her inability to financially provide for the gene editing procedure or refusal to submit her body to the vagaries of this procedure? This is not a social sacrifice; it is the female sacrifice hailed by society as necessary and just. It is the declaration that a woman must sacrifice herself for her womb to thrive. While Savulescu’s stance that the fact that gene editing can be used for nefarious purposes shouldn’t “warrant a moratorium on its use”, is somewhat logical, it is possible in the same vein to declare that if the main purpose behind gene editing was to save a life, the woman's life is also worth the same motive. His argument that “technology can and must be controlled by laws” fails to indicate that the law can be used against the woman. The use of IVF has also allowed the privileged more privilege by allowing for surrogacy through the financially challenged and women of color. With gene-editing technology, the divide is bound to expand.

Germ-line gene editing’s desire to change the future after its arrival can be achieved through ectogenesis. Feminists have teased the idea of an artificial womb for decades to various degrees of approval. Simonstein gives a detailed list of the oppositions various feminist on the spectrum have towards the idea of ectogenesis. The idea of an artificial womb is fraught with the perils of reimagining an entrapment as a savior and vice versa. Simonstein argues that some feminists argue against it because of the view that “female biology is inherently debilitating and something women should be glad [to] escape” instead of an empowering medium (Simonstein, 2017). The idea of weaponizing the enslaving instrument is not a new one. However, in this context, the womb should not be viewed as a separate entity from the woman. Beauvoir declares that the man “thinks of his body as a direct and normal connection with the world, which he apprehends objectively…” (Beauvoir, 1952). The woman must not regard herself as inhabited by the womb. It is neither a source of distress nor of supreme authority. It is the source of whatever power each individual woman deems it to be. This critique functions according to Foucauldian ideology explicated by Peters, as a “care of the self” (Peters, 2010). It does not “condemn new genomic technologies but returns us to the question of the self and the question of care in the pursuit of good life” (Peters, 2010).

Simonstein explains that other feminists fear the release of monopoly of women on reproduction and the possible marginalization and subsequent increment of male reproductive power. While this idea carries the flicker of latent incendiary motifs, the financial divide is an obstacle. It will further marginalize women of color and those with limited financial means. It will merely serve as a means to serve the wealthy. Economic power is intensely patriarchal, which serves as a further disservice to women. However, the artificial womb is neither an enslaving nor liberation tool, it is merely another emblematic contraption. Simonstein further explicates that “women’s role in reproduction is socially cultivated and assimilated” (Simonstein, 2017). The woman’s role should be of her determination. A possible effect of ectogenesis is the construction of what “real pregnancy” means. Either way, the womb does not make the woman. It latches on to her for life. With this knowledge, she returns from her exile.

Works Cited

Stevenson, Christine. “What CRISPR and gene editing means for women’s reproductive health.” Bottle Magazine. 2016.

Simonstein, Frida. “Gene Editing, Enhancing and Women’s Role.” Science and Engineering Ethics. 2017. 1-10.

Happe, Kelly. “The Political Economy of Genetics for Feminists.” University of Michigan Library Technology/Technologies, vol. 13, 1998-1999.

Beauvoir, Simone de. The Second Sex. New York: Vintage Books 1989, 1952.

Levine, Judith. “What Human Genetic Modification Means for Women.” WorldWatch. 2002.

Ribbens, Julia. “Mothers and their Children. A Feminist Sociology of Childrearing.” Family and Relationships. 1994, pp. 6-46.

Savulescu, Julian. Pugh, Jonathan. Douglas, Thomas. Gyngell, Christopher. “The Moral Imperative to Continue Gene Editing Research on Human Embryos.” Protein & Cell. vol 6, issue 7, 2015, pp. 476-479.

Doudna, Jennifer and Sternberg, Samuel. “The Reckoning.” A Crack in Creation: Gene Editing and the Unthinkable Power to Control Evolution. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, 2017. 184-211.

Peters, M. Venkatesan, P. “Biocapitalism and the Politics of Life.” Geopolitics, History and International Relations. vol. 2, no. 2, pp 100-122, 2010.